Read full story for latest details.
Facts
You are an owner-occupant within an association. You operate a business office out of your residence. The CC&R's provide that your residence can only be used for residential purposes. The association notifies you that you must discontinue your business because it violates the residential use restriction in the CC&R's. Can the association force you to discontinue your business?
Legal Analysis
Most CC&R's restrict the use of a residence to a residential purpose. However, CC&R's vary as to how "residential" is defined. Some prohibit all commercial activity. Others will allow some types of home occupation businesses provided certain pre-conditions are met. Therefore, the first step must be a careful reading of the CC&R's, particularly as it relates to the definition of residential use.
The next step is an analysis of the applicable case law and statutory authorities. Most of the case law in this area is developed in connection with public agencies, such as cities or counties, prohibiting or permitting some type of commercial activity in an R-1 residential zone. These cases are helpful but not necessarily controlling in the context of homeowners associations. The following cases are illustrative of public agency cases: A part-time beauty parlor was held to violate the residential use restriction. Biagini v. Hyde (1970) 3 Cal. App. 3d 877. However, many other home occupations have been permitted, including the writing of a syndicated column (City of Beverly Hills v. Brady (1950) 34 Cal. 2d 854), practicing law (County of Butte v. Bach (1985) 172 Cal. App. 3d 848), and conducting a real estate business (Jones v. Robertson (1947) 79 Cal. App. 2d 813).
It may be helpful for you to review the public agency's zoning ordinance regarding home based business in an R-1 zone.
There are several types of businesses that are statutorily permitted in an R-1 zone, as well as in an association with a residential use restriction. One such business is a residential care facility comprising 6 or fewer persons (Health & Safety Code sections 1500-1567.8.) This applies to facilities for the physically disabled, mentally impaired, abused and neglected children. See also, the Federal Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601-3631.) Another protected facility is a family day care home. This consists of 14 or fewer children in a providers home for less than 24 hours. These uses cannot be prohibited. Health & Safety Code section 1597.40(c); Barrett v. Dawson (1998) 61 Cal. App. 4th 1048; Broadmoor San Clemente Homeowners Association v. Nelson (1994) 25 Cal. App. 4th 1.
Efforts to restrict the number of unrelated persons living in a residence have generally been unsuccessful. In City of Santa Barbara v. Adamson (1980) 27 Cal. 3d 123, the Supreme Court held that a city ordinance that did not restrict the number of related persons living within a residence, but restricted the number of unrelated persons living in a residence to 5, was invalid. Similarly, in College Area Renters and Landlord Association v. City of San Diego (1996) 43 Cal. App. 4th 677, there was a city limit on the number of persons over 18 years of age living in a non-owner occupied residence. This limitation was held to be invalid. In both of these cases, the restrictions were imposed by a public agency. While persuasive, these cases were not controlling in the context of a homeowners association.
The author has been involved in three noteworthy cases that involve the issue of the residential use restriction within an association.
In the first case, a film producer who was an owner/occupant in an upscale association wished to produce a "reality show" for a TV series based on the lives of persons living within the association. The show was based on interviews conducted with the residents and discussions between the residents and their family members and neighbors. The association objected to this filming because by filming the common areas such as the club house, the golf course and the entrance way, the identity of the association would be readily determined by persons familiar with the community and would caste the association in a negative fashion. The association contended that the filming was contrary to the residential use requirement specified in the CC&R's. The film producer, who was represented by the undersigned, contended that the filming was not a violation of the residential use restriction. The association threatened to but did not initiate a court action to block the filming and/or production. The show was produced and it was popularly received on television.
In the second case, a resident within a gated senior association was conducting a school in her residence. Somewhere between 10 to 20 children arrived by car who were taught and/or tutored at the owner's residence by the owner. The association believed that this was a non-residential use contrary to the CC&R's. The association filed an action against the owner. The case is currently pending and a trial date has not yet been set.
In the third case, an owner remodeled his two-story residence, so that the only access to his second story was by an outside stairway. On the second story, there were three separate living units. The owner had effectively converted his single family residence into a four-plex. The owner discontinued this use when the association threatened enforcement action based on Hill v. Ghamaty (2006) 143 Cal. App. 4th 1156.
Conclusion
Turning to the case of a home-based business, some of the issues the court will consider are: (a) the number of patients, vendors and employees visiting on a daily basis, (b) the number of vehicles and the duration of stay of the vehicles and (c) the adverse impact on the neighbors. Based on the above referenced cases, the issue is whether a your business is more like a beauty parlor or more like an attorney's office or a real estate office. The answer may depend on the volume of business activity and whether the association has permitted any other home-based businesses. There is no clear answer.
Barry A. Ross is a member of the Real Estate Section and the Business Litigation Section of the Orange County Bar Association. Mr. Ross represents property owners in disputes with their homeowners associations. Mr. Ross can be reached at 949-727-0977 or http://www.RossRealEstateLaw.com
Teenagers WeightEnvironmental Consulting Business PlansConsulting Firms In AtlantaWhat Is A Mechanics Lien ForeclosureWorkers Compensation Fee ScheduleReal Estate Foreclosures TexasConsumer Reports On TiresOnline Law DegreesTeens Freak Dancing24 Hour Legal Advice7 Day Diets For Heart PatientsAt&t Credit CardForeign Movie PostersWilson Golf Clubs For SaleThings To Do In Louisville KyMost Popular Fad DietsHow Much Do Management Consultants MakeLakeland Florida Golf CoursesHumana Health InsuranceMathematics PuzzlesWhat Is A Baseline StudyVirgin Credit Cards AustraliaBunco Card GameUnderstanding Business InsuranceRipped Fuel FaqWachovia Bank Mortgage RatesWedding Industry ProfileHorror DvdsDvd Covers ArchiveInstant Decision Credit CardFree Psp ProgramFull Tilt PokerHistory Of Human ResourcesGaming ProductsLargest Credit Card CompaniesMega Health InsuranceAuto Insurance Rating BasisAllstate EmploymentLocal Golf CoursesSix Sigma ApproachExplain Buy To Let Mortgages0 Balance Transfers On Credit CardsConsulting Service FeesFigure Out Mortgage PaymentsTracking Internet Leads3 Day DietsChurchill Pet InsuranceCallaway Golf Equipment OnlineWrongful Foreclosure LitigationColleges In Los AngelesInterest Only 3 Year MortgagesSample Contracts For Wedding ProfessionalBathing SuitsSitemapSection 8 Rental Assistance ProgramProbability Poker HandsBuying A Car With Bad CreditFast Ways To Lose WeightWet Jeans RippedCompletely Free MoviesCredit Cards FastGolf Equipment Suppliers In ChinaWhite Marsh MallWma Mp3 ComparisonMinnesota Golf AssociationBilliard Table PlansNexia BiotechnologiesTop Life Insurance CompaniesFinancial ConsultantProgressive Scan TvLos Angeles, Ca ForecastTexaco Credit CardsTexas Rigged WormBankruptcy Secured Credit CardPhone Number For Allstate InsuranceHelp Before My House Is Foreclose OnGuardian Angel TattooGrapefruit Diet PlanDefinition Of Human Resource ManagementHouston Private Golf CoursesLocal Poker PlayersE Business ConsultingVideo Poker HelpTraining In Human Resources ConsultingMrDvd Ripper DownloadPoker Tournament ScheduleAccenture Uk LtdRestaurant Industry NewsReview Of L A Weight Loss CenterCalifornia BankruptcyHow Much Do Hematologists Earn?Legal Nurse Consultant Job DescriptionSouth Carolina Golf Courses SaleCasino EquipmentFee Free RemortgagesWhat Is The Employment Outlook For A LawyerThe Enron StoryDownloadable Free DvdsFlorida Golf CoursesGolf Courses In Southwest EnglandFree Health Insurance For MinorsArt Posters ChefsCompare Credit Cards In UkUsing Metformin For Weight LossDiscount DvdHow Do Consultants Get ClientsFree Exercise RoutinesCalorie Consumption For Weight LossTibia HacksBest Golf Course In TennesseeUsed Nike Golf ClubsDrGeneral Electric Dryer RepairWeight Loss OperationMassachusetts LotteryGolf Club RankingsDivorce Attorney In GeorgiaNon Profit Job OpportunitiesNew Jersey ColonyLawyer Income GraphSchools And Human Resource IssuesFree Bad Credit Personal LoansAllstate Motor ClubFrequently Asked Mortgage Refinancing Questions5 Year Adjustable Rate MortgageExplain Human Resource ManagementFica ScoreCheap AdipexSupplier Cobra Golf ClubsApartments In Louisville, KyBank Foreclosures MassachusettsChess Sets UkNames Of Secured Credit Card CompaniesWar Card GameNo Income Verification Home LoansGovernment Assistance With ForeclosureWill I Benefit From RefinancingBad Credit Mortgage RefinancePortrait Of Joan Of ArcCredit Cards For High School SeniorsChange In Irs Flexible Spending AccountsPoker TipsWhat Is The Foreclosure Process In Illinois?MoviedownloadsVideo PokerFree Zeppelin BootlegsDetermining Consultant RatesInteresting Facts About FloridaRequired Skills To Be A LawyerDragonball Z IconsLearn To WrestleBusiness Plans OnlineObtaining Credit ReportsImage Consultant Atlanta125cc Motorbike Free InsuranceToy Slot MachinesFat LossGolf Courses In BuckinghamshireHow Much Money Do Fashion Consultants Make?Gmac Real EstateDefinition Of BpoCommercial Insurance CompaniesPrivate Investors Pre ForeclosuresObtaining A Loan After ForeclosureSan Diego AirportWeight Loss ShotsAfrican American AttorneysWhat Is Industrial Marketing In The WebCriminal Defense AttorneysKemp Poker CardsMerchant Account Intangibles Payment FreeReturn On InvestmentCalculate Credit Card InterestCommercial Real Estate CompaniesFree Tips For Loosing Weight30 Second Approval Credit CardsFree Downloadable SpadesCredit Card After BankruptcyFree Service Agreement FormsForgiveness Of Debt TaxCompare Uk Credit CardsMortgage Transfer DealsFortis Car InsuranceMbna Online AccessLowest Jumbo Mortgage RatesForeclosed Homes In MarylandWisconsin Golf Course ReviewsCredit Card Generation SoftwareSweep Accounts WorkSample New Business Budget AnalysisCheat At PokerList Of Merchant BanksWindows Xp SkinsIndependent Computer ConsultingDictionary For Real Estate TermsCommunication Consulting CompaniesPatent Lawyers UkHow Much Does A Legal Nurse Consultant MakeRetainer Agreement FinancialRenters Insurance MichiganPortable Credit Card ReaderSteps To Becoming An AttorneyUs Bank MergerPeoplesoft ResourcesHuman Resource Consulting SingaporeColumbia South CarolinaPoker Stars CodeCredit Card Payment SystemsIllinois Foreclosed HomesCredit Repair ServicesHealth Insurance Rates For SmokersThings To Do In FloridaCorporate Image DesignPersonal Life Insurance High RiskBest Of Russell SimmonsInsurance Deductible AmountQuick Fighting TipsReview Of Ladies Golf ClubsHistory Of Mortgage Interest RatesNames Of Popular DietsWholesale Poker CardsMotorcycle Insurance CanadaConsulting Engineers Of South CarolinaFree Downloadable ScreensaversGolf Courses In BournemouthHow Does A Libor Mortgage WorkHackers Free Credit Card NumbersMonogram Credit Card Bank Of GeorgiaCredit Building Credit CardsWhat Is The Foreclosure Process In NcHistorical Conforming Mortgage RatesPartylite Consultant PageManagement Information Systems CareersDream MeaningsHastings Car InsuranceNorwich UnionPoker Dictionary SiteClinical Psychology ReviewGeneralist SpeciesCustomized Playing CardsA Day In The Life A Corporate LawyerBudget Car Rental Online CouponFannie Mae ForeclosuresDefine Information ServicesProbability LessonsMain Sequence StarsLso SoccerFree Business Insurance QuotesCat SoundsConsulting Firms In DcBest Deal RemortgagesWeight Loss Support GroupsSmoking PotCanadian Car InsuranceInteresting Facts On Puerto RicoCard Player MagazineHow To Be A Licensed Commercial Mortgage BrokerInternational Environmental MovementCommercial Insurance UnderwritersMortgage Lenders Network UsaWeight Loss CampOccupation Yearly IncomeRagnarok Online Hunter SkillsLocal Tattoo ParlorsAdvantages Of Accepting Credit CardsIndividual Health InsuranceWisconsin Public RecordsShoot DieMedia File SharingAmerican Home Mortgage LocationsAmerican Family Insurance Agents In ArizonaRestaurant Menu Graphic DesignMortgage Loan ForeclosuresRussell Simmons ChildhoodCoverage Features Of Private Health InsuranceClinton MckinzieAddress For Chase Manhattan BankGolf Courses In ChepstowCredit Cards For MinorsPersonal Dental InsuranceKpmg Ch2m Hill Canada LtdBest Worst Weight Loss SupplementsQuick Weight Loss ExercisesHome Business MortgageWeight Loss Spa OregonMiniature Golf Course LayoutsStraight HairIs Rental Car Insurance NecessaryReal Time Mortgage LeadsVisa Starter CardsFree Credit CheckCompare Rates Of Merchant Card ServicesFlorida Real Estate SchoolsAre Referral Fees TaxableLichtenstein CastleRefinancing Mortgage ScamsProper Punching TechniquesHuman Resource IssuesHomeowner Association LawSkills Need To Become A LawyerCanadian Credit RepairSmall Loans For People With Bad CreditLawyer Salary IncomeWeight Loss ResortsGame Table ChairsYoga PracticesBusiness Credit Card SecuredMalls In Houston TexasSample Of A Proposal PaperHow To Deal With ForeclosureKelly Staffing ServicesWhat Are The Big 5 Consulting Companies?Visa Buxx CardCredit Card BankruptcyGeorgia Public School SystemsHow Big A Mortgage Can I GetFunny Short MoviesHindi Karaoke SongsContingency Patent LawyersDeloitte LondonFuture Mortgage Interest RatesHome Video EditingWedding Consulting BusinessDvd Backup OsxTop Mortgage CompaniesLow Carb Diet PlansInternational Federation Of Competitive EatingObesity Surgery UkLowes Movie TheaterGolf CollectiblesFree Corporate ImagesPing Golf Equipment Retailers In The UkSmart Home ConsultingBudget DeficitGovernment Small Business GrantsStrategic Human Resource Development OutsourcingIt Consulting JobsWhat Is The Difference Between Fha And Hud Loans?Sr22 Auto InsurancePoker Chips WholesaleHuman Resource Laws IllinoisList Of Information Technology CompaniesGastric BandingEstate Agents In Romford EssexPool Table DimensionsSavannah GeorgiaVa Foreclosures In FloridaSouth Carolina State FlowerBad Credit Unsecured Credit CardsGeneral Liability Insurance OverviewMail Order BridesWeight Loss CruiseDefine Mortgage LoansNorthern Virginia Wedding Reception SitesPrivate Schools Northern VirginiaList The Five Phases Of The Lytic CycleDitech ComplaintsLas Vegas InformationFacts About Fad DietsList Of Golf Courses In ColoradoEmotional WellnessFree Real Estate Foreclosure ListingsSan Diego Police DepartmentWatch Dbz ClipsTravel Insurance BrokersGolf Courses In Northern SpainForeclosure Laws In OhioDefinition Of A Fashion ConsultantFree Diet Pills UkSuperior Staffing ServicesOutline Map Of North AmericaDownload Spiderman EpisodesBariatric Surgery In OhioWriting Sets UkBruce Almighty TrailerMetformin Congestive Heart FailureMagic TricksFun PokerVa Foreclosure HomesStories About ForgivenessMortgage Companies In IllinoisMortgage To Buy AbroadFree Music LyricsAccenture ChicagoRefinance ListCopy DvdNeed Human Resource ArticlesPinehurst Golf CourseWhat Does Bpo Stand ForNews 12 Long IslandAnd1 Basketball WallpaperForeclosure Listings In CanadaApproved Personal Loan For Bad CreditFondue Sets UkAmerican Home Mortgage WebsiteWork ContractsFarmers Insurance AgencyAttorney DirectoryLegal Foreclosure ProceedingsMetropolitan Life InsuranceCan Green Tea Really Make You Lost WeightDvd Ripping FreewareMembers National Security CouncilPinkerton Computer ConsultantsGrants To Help Stop ForeclosureFast Weight Loss RemediesScarface ArtCanadian Mortgage AdviceBeer DiceInternational Merchant Account ProviderLong Island ClubsProcess Consulting ToolsComplaints Against Mortgage CompaniesChurchill Holiday InsuranceDvd Burning ErrorsGastric Bypass PillWhat Is The Salary Range For An Image Consultant?Kpmg Peat Marwick Accounting FirmManagement Consulting ModelHuman Resource Management Free ArticlesThe Consulting CycleBuilding Supplies OnlineHollywood VideoCathouse Poker RunLeader Mortgage Company, LlcDvd Bootleg ArtworkForeclosure WebsitesMatrix Reloaded CharactersBuckeyes Poker ChipsPrivate Poker LessonsDbz Movie ReviewsCompare Fixed Mortgage RatesMovie Screenplay DatabaseDownload Ragnarok Online BetaPhysicians For Social ResponsibilityFuneral Home ConsultingShowcase Cinema MoviesHud Loan GlossaryFashion Consulting CareersParty PokerPampered Chef ConsultantEntertainment Lawyers FloridaChicago Yellow PagesBusiness Creative Marketing ConsultingDivx DvdProvidian Bank Secured Credit CardGothika Movie TrailerMortgage Broker Listings
0 Responses to “U.S. currency sinks to new low”
Leave a Reply